How Manchester United Stunned Manchester City in the 2024 FA Cup Final The Rise of Garnacho and Mainoo in a Thrilling 2-1 Victory

How Manchester United Defeated Manchester City 2-1 in the 2024 FA Cup Final with Goals from Garnacho and Mainoo. Read on for a Full Match Analysis and Key Highlights.

The 2024 FA Cup final delivered a pulsating encounter between Manchester United and Manchester City, with the Red Devils emerging victorious in a hard-fought 2-1 win. Goals from Alejandro Garnacho and Kobbie Mainoo sealed the triumph, spoiling Pep Guardiola's dreams of a consecutive domestic double. Erik ten Hag’s tactical acumen shone through, as his side avenged last season's heart-wrenching defeat in the same fixture.

How Manchester United Stunned Manchester City in the 2024 FA Cup Final: The Rise of Garnacho and Mainoo in a Thrilling 2-1 Victory

How Manchester United Stunned Manchester City in the 2024 FA Cup Final: A Masterclass in Tactical Discipline and Counter-Attacking Prowess

Manchester United entered the final at Wembley with a clear game plan: stay compact, exploit mistakes, and strike on the counter. From the outset, United's defense was organized and resilient, with Raphael Varane and Lisandro Martinez forming an impenetrable barrier. The midfield trio of Scott McTominay, Sofyan Amrabat, and the young Kobbie Mainoo provided both stability and creativity, crucially supporting the attacking transitions.

First Half: United's Early Breakthroughs 

The breakthrough came on the half-hour mark when a miscommunication between City's goalkeeper Stefan Ortega and defender Josko Gvardiol allowed Alejandro Garnacho to capitalize. Garnacho’s relentless pressing forced the error, and he coolly slotted the ball into an open net, sending the United fans into raptures.

Nine minutes later, Manchester United doubled their lead with a beautifully orchestrated counter-attack. Marcus Rashford's precise diagonal pass found Garnacho on the wing. Garnacho deftly combined with Bruno Fernandes, who then set up Kobbie Mainoo for a clinical first-time finish beyond Ortega. The fluidity and precision of this move epitomized United's counter-attacking prowess and left Manchester City reeling.

Second Half: City’s Late Surge 

Manchester City, renowned for their attacking flair, struggled to break down United's disciplined defense. Erling Haaland, City's talismanic striker, had a rare off day, epitomized by his powerful shot that rattled the crossbar on 55 minutes. Guardiola's side appeared increasingly frustrated as they failed to penetrate United's defensive lines.

As the second half progressed, City intensified their efforts. Substitute Jeremy Doku provided a spark, and his persistence paid off three minutes from time. Doku's 20-yard shot found the back of the net, squeezing past Andre Onana at the near post. This goal ignited hopes of a comeback, but United's resolve held firm, and they saw out the match to secure the trophy.

How Manchester United Stunned Manchester City in the 2024 FA Cup Final: The Rise of Garnacho and Mainoo in a Thrilling 2-1 Victory

Key Performances: Varane and Mainoo Stand Out 

Raphael Varane was a colossus in defense, earning the Player of the Match accolade. His leadership and positional awareness were instrumental in nullifying City's formidable attack. This performance marked a fitting end to Varane's United career, as he announced his retirement from professional football post-match.

Kobbie Mainoo, the young midfielder, delivered a mature and composed performance beyond his years. His goal was a testament to his technical ability and vision. Mainoo's emergence this season has been a bright spot for United, providing hope for the future amidst a challenging campaign.

How Manchester United Stunned Manchester City in the 2024 FA Cup Final: The Rise of Garnacho and Mainoo in a Thrilling 2-1 Victory

A Season of Contrasts: Triumph Amidst Turmoil 

For Manchester United, the FA Cup victory provided a much-needed silver lining to an otherwise turbulent season. Despite registering their worst Premier League finish in decades, lifting the FA Cup for the 13th time secured European football for the next season. This triumph could potentially save Erik ten Hag’s job, although speculation about his future persists. Reports suggest the Dutchman might face a similar fate to Louis van Gaal, who was dismissed days after winning the 2016 FA Cup.

Manchester City: A Missed Opportunity 

For Manchester City, the defeat was a bitter pill to swallow. Having just secured their fourth consecutive Premier League title, the prospect of achieving back-to-back league and FA Cup doubles was tantalizingly close. However, their performance in the final was uncharacteristically lackluster, with key players unable to rise to the occasion. Guardiola’s side, usually so dominant, appeared out of sorts and struggled to impose their rhythm on the game.

Player Ratings Manchester United

• Andre Onana: 8 – Made crucial saves and commanded his area well.
• Aaron Wan-Bissaka: 9 – Exceptional defensively and supported the attack effectively.
• Diogo Dalot: 8 – Solid defensively, provided width going forward.
• Lisandro Martinez: 9 – Formed a formidable partnership with Varane.
• Raphael Varane: 9* – A defensive masterclass, vital in keeping Haaland quiet.
• Sofyan Amrabat: 8 – Tireless in midfield, broke up City’s play.
• Kobbie Mainoo: 9 – Mature performance, crucial goal.
• Scott McTominay: 8 – Strong and combative, supported both defense and attack.
• Bruno Fernandes: 8 – Creative and industrious, key in transitions.
• Alejandro Garnacho: 9 – Electric pace, pressing led to the opening goal.
• Marcus Rashford: 8 – Provided a constant threat, key pass for the second goal.

Manchester City

• Stefan Ortega: 5 – Error for the first goal, shaky overall.
• Kyle Walker: 7 – Defended well, tried to drive the team forward.
• Josko Gvardiol: 5 – Mistake led to the first goal, looked unsettled.
• Nathan Ake: 6 – Solid but struggled against United’s pace.
• John Stones: 6 – Composed but unable to influence the game.
• Rodri: 6 – Battled hard in midfield, but couldn’t dominate.
• Mateo Kovacic: 6 – Industrious but lacked cutting edge.
• Kevin De Bruyne: 5 – Below par, struggled to create.
• Phil Foden: 5 – Anonymous for large spells.
• Bernardo Silva: 5 – Failed to make an impact.
• Erling Haaland: 5 – Starved of service, hit the bar once.

How Manchester United Stunned Manchester City in the 2024 FA Cup Final: The Rise of Garnacho and Mainoo in a Thrilling 2-1 Victory

Conclusion 

Manchester United's victory over Manchester City in the 2024 FA Cup final will be remembered as a masterclass in tactical discipline and counter-attacking football. Erik ten Hag's men executed their game plan to perfection, with standout performances from Varane and Mainoo leading the way. For City, it was a rare off day that denied them another piece of history. As the dust settles, the triumph at Wembley provides a glimmer of hope for United's future, while City will undoubtedly regroup and return stronger next season.